The five most controversial ‘Big Brother’ moments: from racism scandals to brawls
Los Angeles, California: ‘Big Brother USA’ has been enthralling audiences with its intense drama, strategic gameplay and unexpected twists since it first aired in 2000. However, in addition to being entertaining, the show has sparked significant controversy over the years. From shocking displays of racism and aggressive behavior to physical altercations and rule-breaking activities, these moments shocked viewers.
Below, we discuss five of the most controversial moments in ‘Big Brother USA’ history, the dark side of reality TV, and the impact these events have had on the show’s legacy.
Racism Scandal (Season 15, 2013)
The 15th season of ‘Big Brother USA’ is notorious for numerous racist and offensive comments made by several houseguests. Contestants such as Erin Grice, Ginamarie Zimmerman, and Spencer Clawson made derogatory comments about their fellow housemates, including racist, homophobic, and misogynistic slurs. The comments were broadcast on live feed and quickly sparked outrage among viewers The backlash was so intense that Erin and Ginamarie lost their jobs outside the home because of their behavior. The controversy led to extensive discussion about racism and discrimination in the context of the show and in society at large.
‘Big Brother’ contestants Erin Grice and Ginamarie Zimmerman lose their jobs over comments (@CBS)
Chima Simone’s Ejection (Season 11, 2009)
In Season 11, Chima Simone was kicked out of ‘Big Brother USA’ for repeatedly breaking the show’s rules. Chimera was ejected after multiple rule violations, including dropping her microphone into the pool and refusing to participate in the event’s mandatory activities. His behavior was partly fueled by the unexpected eviction of his associate, Jesse Godderz, which left him feeling betrayed and out of control. Chima’s eviction is a notable moment in the show’s history, bringing a significant amount of controversy to the show.
Chima Simone’s erratic behavior played a role in her elimination (@CBS)
Violent fight between Willie Hantz and Joe Irvin (Season 14, 2012)
In Season 14, Willie Hantz was involved in a physical altercation with fellow houseguest Joe Irvin. The conflict escalates during a heated argument, culminating in Willie headbutting Joe. This act of physical violence led to Willy’s immediate eviction from the house, as ‘Big Brother USA’ has a strict policy against physical aggression. The incident shocked both the houseguests and viewers and marked one of the most controversial moments in the franchise’s history.
Willie Hantz and Joe Irvine had a heated battle on ‘Big Brother’ (@CBS).
Kaitlyn Herman’s Mental Controversy (Season 20, 2018)
Season 20 features Caitlin Herman, who claims to have psychic powers and often makes controversial statements about mental health and spirituality. His erratic behavior and supposed psychic intuition were a source of drama and controversy at home. Kaitlyn’s actions and comments drew widespread criticism from viewers and her fellow guests, who questioned the veracity of her claims and the impact of her behavior on the game. Despite the controversy, Kaitlyn was a central figure in the season, her unpredictability keeping both the houseguests and the audience on edge.
‘Big Brother’ contestant Kaitlyn Herman allegedly had psychic powers (@CBS)
Jackson Michie’s Controversial Win (Season 21, 2019)
Jackson Michie’s win in season 21 was met with controversy due to his aggressive behavior and racially sensitive comments throughout the season. Many viewers and houseguests felt that there should have been consequences for his actions instead of winning. Mitchie’s comments and behavior, particularly towards minority houseguests, sparked significant controversy regarding the show’s handling of racism and similar issues. Despite this controversy, Mitchie won the season, prompting discussion among the show’s fans about the game’s ethics.
Jackson Michie’s ‘Big Brother’ win was full of controversy (@CBS)
‘Big Brother’ Season 26 will premiere for two nights on July 17 and 18